Can you offer a little more information on what you're looking for? That might help to get some relevant responses. For example, what are your priorities in making a decision - water activities such as good snorkeling, good food, an all-inclusive property, low cost.... If you have some specifics, that would be most helpful. Thanks!
We thought St Croix was a bit too busy for us - one side of the island is refineries. Venezuela ships oil to St Croix refineries so the one side of the island was somewhat polluted. The tourist side and downtown center was beautiful and historical however. It just depends how much you actually drive around. We like to explore while some travelers prefer to stay put. Have Fun wherever you decide to go!